Blogs / I Have Several Landing Pages: Which One Should I Fix First?

I Have Several Landing Pages: Which One Should I Fix First?

Nov 19, 20267 min read
Pulkit Khurana

Founder, SproutMe

A line drawing of a wrench, illustrating how to decide which landing page to optimize first by lost conversions.

You have six landing pages, a fixed amount of design time, and a report ranking them by conversion rate. The page at the bottom looks like the obvious target. It usually isn't, and fixing it first can cost a month on a page that barely moves revenue.

Fix the page losing the most conversions in absolute terms, not the one with the lowest rate. Multiply its sessions by the gap between its current and target conversion rate, then by what a conversion is worth. That usually points to your highest-traffic paid page. Pages too small to measure wait, and ease breaks ties.

Why not fix the worst converter first?

Conversion rate is a ratio, and ratios hide volume. A page converting at 1% on a few hundred sessions a month can only recover a handful of conversions, however good you make it. A page converting at 3% on tens of thousands of sessions loses far more with every point it falls short.

The lowest-rate page is also often doing a different job. It might be a top-of-funnel guide, a page fed by cold social traffic, or a campaign page left running after its offer expired. A visitor arriving from a branded search already knows what they want. A visitor arriving from an interest-targeted social ad does not. Comparing raw rates across pages with different traffic compares audiences, not pages.

Paid pages carry a second weight: you are paying for every session. A conversion lost on a paid page is wasted spend on top of lost revenue, and that cost repeats every day the page stays unfixed. When two pages lose similar volume, the paid one goes first.

How do you score each page's lost conversions?

When you decide which landing page to optimize, you need a score that combines volume, gap and value. The arithmetic is simple:

  • Lost conversions = monthly sessions × (target rate − current rate)
  • Lost value = lost conversions × value per conversion

The target rate should come from your own data, not an industry benchmark. Published landing page benchmarks mostly come from page-builder vendors' own customer bases, with a traffic mix you cannot see. Use the best rate a comparable page of yours achieves on the same traffic source, or the page's own rate before it slipped.

Value per conversion is where most rankings go wrong. In e-commerce, use average order value multiplied by margin. In lead generation, pull the lead-to-opportunity rate from your CRM. A form that produces plenty of leads sales never calls back is worth less than its conversion count suggests. It may even be the page you should fix first, for the opposite reason.

Here is a hypothetical example with three pages, all lead-generation pages with the same value per lead:

| Page | Monthly sessions | Current rate | Target rate | Lost conversions | |---|---|---|---|---| | A: paid search | 15,000 | 2.0% | 3.0% | 150 | | B: webinar signup | 1,200 | 0.8% | 3.0% | 26 | | C: pricing | 6,000 | 4.0% | 4.5% | 30 |

Page B has by far the worst rate and ranks last. Page A, which looks merely average, is losing nearly five times as much. If page C's leads close at triple the rate of page A's, the gap narrows. That is why value belongs in the formula.

The tedious part is assembling the table. Sessions live in Analytics, spend lives in each ad platform, and lead quality lives in the CRM. SproutMe Companion answers a question like "which landing page lost us the most qualified leads last month" from unified Google Ads, Meta, Analytics and HubSpot data, so the ranking starts from one view rather than three exports.

When is a page too small to judge?

A page with very little traffic produces a conversion rate that is mostly noise. Two extra signups in a month can double the rate and mean nothing. Don't rank these pages against the rest. Either park them until traffic grows, or group pages built on the same template and judge the template as one unit.

There is one exception. A low-traffic page that sits at the last step before a purchase or demo request still gets checked for outright breakage: a form that fails to submit, a broken mobile layout, a page that takes too long to load. Those aren't optimization. They are repairs, and they jump the queue regardless of score.

Is it the page or the traffic it gets?

Before you commit design time to the top-ranked page, segment its sessions by traffic source and device. The result tells you whether you are fixing a page or a mismatch.

  • One source converts and another doesn't. If paid search visitors convert normally and paid social visitors don't, the page may be fine. The audience or the ad is the problem. A common culprit is a gap between the ad's promise and the page's headline. Checking whether your page says what your ad promised is a faster fix than a redesign.
  • Mobile lags desktop more than on your other pages. Mobile usually converts below desktop everywhere. If this page's gap is unusually wide, the job is a mobile layout fix, which is narrower and cheaper than a rebuild.
  • Visitors leave at a key step. GA4 has no default exit rate metric. You can approximate it by comparing sessions that end on a page with all sessions that visit it, then compare that ratio across your key pages. A high exit rate on a help article can mean success. On a pricing or form page, it usually means friction.
  • An organic page is quietly shrinking. A page losing search positions drops down the landing page report before your total traffic visibly falls. Fixing it early protects volume you would otherwise lose.

If segmentation shows the page itself is the problem across every source and device, the full diagnosis of why a landing page isn't converting is the next step.

How do you break a tie between two pages?

When two pages score close, rank the fixes instead of the pages. ICE scoring works well for this. Rate each candidate fix from one to 10 on Impact, Confidence and Ease, then multiply the three scores.

Your lost-value score already gives you Impact. Confidence should reflect evidence, not enthusiasm: a fix that segmentation points to directly, or that has worked on a sibling page, rates high. A hunch rates low. Ease is the inverse of effort.

This is why a full redesign rarely wins. It scores high on Impact but low on Confidence and Ease. A targeted headline or form fix on your second-ranked page can therefore beat a rebuild of your first. Treat the scores as triage, not truth. They are judgment calls, so use them to decide what to test, then let the test replace the estimate.

Conclusion

The page to fix first is the one losing the most value, not the one with the lowest rate. Score each page by sessions, gap to a realistic target from your own data, and what a conversion is actually worth downstream. Set aside pages too small to measure, and segment the winner before you touch it, so you know whether the problem is the page or its traffic. Re-run the ranking monthly, because traffic mix shifts and last month's priority may not survive it.

See how Companion answers questions like "which landing page cost us the most leads" from your own spend, analytics and CRM data.

Frequently Asked Questions

Use them only as a loose sanity check. Most published landing page benchmarks come from page-builder vendors' own customer data, with an unknown mix of industries, offers and traffic sources. Your own best-performing comparable page, on the same traffic source, is a far more honest target. It reflects your audience, your offer and your price point, which no cross-industry median can.

They matter, but paid pages usually go first when lost volume is similar, because every paid session is spend you have already committed. Organic pages earn priority when they carry large traffic or start losing search positions. A page slipping in rankings drops out of the landing page report before overall traffic falls, which makes it an early warning.

Monthly is a sensible default for most accounts, and immediately after any major change in spend or campaign mix. Traffic shifts between pages as budgets move, offers change and rankings drift. A page that ranked third last month can become your biggest leak after a budget reallocation. The scoring takes minutes once the data sits in one place.

Grow smarter with AI marketing tips

Join our newsletter to get practical insights, automation ideas, and performance tips straight to your inbox.

Get a complimentary audit to uncover AI opportunities hidden in your data.

Put these strategies to work